Bargaining, Rationalization, and Consolation — Chapters 3 and 4 of A Grief Observed

By the time we reach Chapter 3 of A Grief Observed, something in Lewis begins to soften. The raw, unfiltered pain of the earlier chapters gives way to the impulse to make peace — not through understanding, but through reconciliation with the familiar language of faith. His grief, once defiant, begins to seek shape. This is where the book subtly turns: from confrontation to comfort.

I. Bargaining Disguised as Acceptance

Chapter 3 represents Lewis’s quiet negotiation with loss. Having exhausted his anger, he begins to reason with it — to find a frame that makes the pain survivable. He tells himself that his marriage may have reached completion, that its purpose was fulfilled. It’s a gentle form of bargaining, disguised as acceptance: if I can see this as whole, perhaps I can live with it.

This is not exactly self-deception; it’s survival. Lewis, whose intellect had always demanded order, tries to stitch coherence into the senseless, but without his religious scaffolding, he simply cannot do it.

II. The Leg Cut Off Again

Lewis observes that “in grief nothing stays put… the same leg is cut off time after time.” It’s one of his most striking insights — and one of the truest. Grief does not fade; it recurs. The pain returns not because we fail to heal, but because remembering is part of what it means to love.

Yet Lewis’s response to this recurrence is to seek containment. He wants the wound to mean something — to point toward a larger pattern that redeems the repetition. But the repetition itself is the meaning. It is the proof that love endures beyond reason. The wound reopens because we keep living, and living keeps invoking what was lost.

III. Submission Disguised as Resolution

By Chapter 4, Lewis’s bargaining evolves into a quieter form of submission. He decides that his mistake was loving the earthly too much — that his grief is a sign of misplaced devotion. His answer, then, is to reorder his love: to submit first to God and trust that everything else will follow.

It reads as resolution, but it’s really an act of surrender. He cannot sustain the rebellion that defined the earlier chapters; it is too costly. So he returns to the framework that once gave him stability, not because it satisfies his questions, but because it gives him justification to stop asking.

This is the tender paradox of A Grief Observed: Lewis’s faith, so tested, bends under the strain, and in bending, becomes his shelter. He flinches — and in doing so, he survives.

IV. Acceptance Without Bargaining

Calvin McShane’s acceptance in A Pleasant Fiction is different in form but not in spirit. He does not bargain with the universe for meaning, nor does he submit to mystery for comfort. Instead, he acknowledges that his family’s lives were meaningful because they were lived — that their presence shaped him, and their absence continues to.

His acceptance is not about replacing pain with purpose but integrating both into the same truth: love matters even when it ends. In accepting their deaths, Calvin also accepts his own mortality — the inevitability that he, too, will one day exist only in memory. And eventually, not even that. This is not resignation; it’s recognition. To live fully is to accept that meaning does not depend on permanence.

V. Conclusion: The Consolations We Choose

Chapters 3 and 4 of A Grief Observed mark the point where Lewis turns back from the edge. Having stared into the silence and found no answer, he reaches for the language of faith—not as a conclusion, but as comfort. His bargaining and submission are not failures of belief, but the natural recoil of someone who has nowhere else to go. He returns to the story that steadies him, the one that lets him go on living. It’s not cowardice; it’s human.

Calvin’s acceptance in A Pleasant Fiction moves along a different path but toward the same horizon of peace. He does not search for meaning in what happened so much as affirm the meaning that remains. His parents, his brother, his child—they are gone, but not erased. Their lives mattered because they were lived, and because he carries them forward. The continuity is not mystical; it is human.

“They matter,” Calvin says. “Because I’m still here.” And even when he is no longer, he still was.

That is his faith—not in eternity as promise, but in existence as fact. Death ends a life, not its significance. The traces endure in memory, in influence, in the quiet ways love alters what survives it.

Lewis finds solace in returning to the eternal he once knew.

Calvin finds solace in recognizing that what was real remains real, even when it’s gone.

Both seek a way to live with absence. One leans into faith; the other into being.

And between them lies the full measure of grief: the need to make meaning, and the grace of realizing that sometimes, meaning is already there.

© 2025 Chapelle Dorée Publishing, LLC. All rights reserved. This content may not be reproduced, distributed, or modified without permission.